Leave a Message

Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.

Penny O'Brien Naperville, IL Real Estate Agent Headshot

Penny O'Brien

Get To Know Me

Proven Performance. Personal Service.

With 13 years in real estate, Penny O’Brien has built her business on exceptional service, thoughtful strategy, and a steadfast commitment to her clients. A longtime Naperville resident and experienced Naperville REALTOR®, Penny is known for her energy, confidence, and attention to detail. She takes the time to understand what matters most to each client and creates a tailored approach designed around their individual goals.

For sellers, that strategy often begins well before a home reaches the market. Whether working with a first-time home seller, longtime homeowner, empty nester preparing to downsize, or someone navigating a major life transition, Penny helps make the process clear and manageable. She has a keen eye for identifying the pre-market improvements that can have the greatest impact on presentation and value. From paint, carpet, and lighting to thoughtful updates and finishing details, she helps sellers determine what is worth doing and what isn’t. Every seller also receives a complimentary consultation with a professional staging company, providing expert guidance on presenting the home beautifully for today’s buyer.

For buyers, Penny combines extensive knowledge of Naperville and the western suburbs with a strong understanding of neighborhoods, schools, market values, and current market conditions. Whether helping first-time buyers, move-up buyers, those relocating to the area, downsizing, or finding the right home for their next chapter, Penny provides experienced guidance from the initial search through closing. She helps buyers evaluate value, understand the nuances of each neighborhood, structure competitive offers, and negotiate strategically, always keeping their goals at the center of the process.

With more than 600 homes sold and over $300 million in career sales, Penny brings deep market knowledge, skilled negotiation, and a sophisticated marketing approach to every transaction. Her focus is not simply on getting a home sold or helping a buyer find a house, but on developing the right strategy, protecting her clients’ interests, and achieving the strongest possible result while providing highly personalized service from beginning to end.

2025 by the Numbers (Close Up These Spaces)

  • $27 Million Closed Sales Volume
  • 38 Homes Sold
  • $728,000 Average Sales Price
  • 17 Average Days on Market
  • 101.3% Average Sale-to-List Price

Recognition & Accolades

  • RealTrends Verified — Top 1.5% of Individual Real Estate Agents in America
  • RealTrends — #5 City Rank
  • RealTrends — #127 Illinois State Rank
  • Top 10 Agent in Naperville
  • Top 1% of Real Estate Agents in Illinois
  • Baird & Warner — Top 1% in Sales Volume
  • Baird & Warner Founders Club
  • Chicago Agent Magazine — Top-Producing Real Estate Agent
  • Chicago Agent Magazine — Who’s Who
  • Glancer Magazine Readers’ Choice — Best REALTOR®
What My Clients Say

Penny did a fantastic job of selling our house. We live out of state, and Penny navigated through tough tenants during COVID and sold our house above asking price. Penny coordinated everything for us and took the stress out of selling a house. Thank you, Penny, for all your support!

— Asin S.

What My Clients Say

Penny was wonderful to work with. She and her team were very organized and provided consistent communication and feedback on our progress throughout the home-selling process. We received valuable advice on how to prep the home based on our specific needs, and the home sold right away with multiple offers. We highly recommend Penny.

— Ryan L

What My Clients Say

Penny knows how to price, stage, and sell a home. Even in a hot market, Penny advised us well on the improvements we should make. We took her advice on everything, and it paid off. She has great connections, and through her, we were able to get painting of the entire house! Her professional relationships put us at the top of the queue; this was essential to getting a home on the market at the right time....

— Eva T.

What My Clients Say

Penny was both my listing and buying agent. She is professional, knowledgeable, and was able to sell my home for the full list price in three days! She is a joy to work with, and I cannot recommend her highly enough. Choose Penny, and you will not regret it.

— Swapnali P.

What My Clients Say

We had been searching for our dream home in the Naperville area for a while. That was when we met Penny at an open house for one of her listings. We found her to be very professional, respectful, confident, and very knowledgeable about Naperville. Based on our first interaction at the open house and our own research, we decided to ask Penny to help us with our search. She was quickly able to zero in on a...

— Abhishek T.

What My Clients Say

Penny did exactly what she told us she would do! We loved working with Penny. She had an excellent stager and photographer to help set the sale of our house up for success. We sold our house in the first weekend with 20+ showings and 8 offers. We highly recommend her to anyone!

— Amy H.

What My Clients Say

Penny outlined a process from the very beginning, and while I thought it was very optimistic, it happened exactly as she said it would. She kept my wife and me very much up to date throughout the entire process. Simply put, she was professional, knowledgeable, and all-around amazing. She single-handedly kept us calm throughout the process.

— James H.

What My Clients Say

Penny was great to work with while purchasing our home. We were looking for a specific area of Naperville, and we were not in any rush to purchase. She was knowledgeable about the area and the current market. Once we found the house we wanted to purchase, she guided us through making an offer, negotiation, inspection, and closing processes. We would highly recommend Penny!

— Maureen S.

What My Clients Say

Penny and her team are consummate professionals. Penny is assertive but not aggressive. She is an expert without coming off as a know-it-all. She is 100% responsive to every inquiry. She is creative, and she used several unique marketing tools that set our home apart from the neighborhood. We could not be more impressed and pleased with her approach as well as the outcome of our sale. We recommend her se...

— David H.

What My Clients Say

We cannot recommend Penny O'Brien enough! Working with Penny was a wonderful experience. Penny and her team were professional throughout every aspect of the sale of our home. With the guidance and help of Penny, we were able to list, acquire multiple offers, and become under contract within the first 48 hours of listing. Penny and her team handled every detail of the sale, including the staging of our ho...

— Kristin W.

What My Clients Say

Penny was great throughout our house-selling experience. Both she and her support team were professional and timely in our interactions. Her advice and hard work helped us sell our house in one weekend! This was exceptional and greatly reduced the stress of our selling experience. We highly recommend her if you are looking for a knowledgeable agent who will help you get top dollar for your home.

— Bobbie R.

What My Clients Say

There’s a reason that Penny is one of the highest-rated agents in the industry. Simply put, she cares about her clients more than herself. She is especially skilled at understanding that no two transactions are alike, and her ability to quickly adjust to always-changing dynamics is impressive. So, stop wasting your time searching and hire Penny O’Brien!

— David P.

What My Clients Say

We called Penny on the recommendation of our neighbors who had used her to sell their homes. Even though she knew we were referred by happy clients, Penny came to our first meeting fully prepared with a market analysis and point of view. She did her homework and didn't take anything for granted, even before meeting us. Once we decided to use Penny, we set an aggressive 3-week goal to get our house ready ...

— Steve W.

What My Clients Say

Penny was an outstanding realtor for us. She did everything she said she would do and more. She is professional, understanding, and truly an expert! She helped us determine what we needed to do to our home to sell it and was able to work around our constraints. We listed our home on a Friday, had an open house on Saturday and Sunday, and received several offers by Sunday night. Sold our home in 3 days! W...

— Nancy C.

What My Clients Say

Penny is simply the best! If you want someone who will listen to your needs, take the time to find the right home, and, importantly, ensure you get a phenomenal deal, look no further! We have used Penny for multiple transactions, and she exceeds expectations! If you want to sell your home, get your dream home, or both, Penny is your person!

— Kids S.

What My Clients Say

Penny and her team were wonderful. Penny did exactly what she said when we first met. She priced our house correctly to get an offer the first weekend. Her team provided full-service support from start to finish. They were in constant communication with us through the entire process, answering all of our questions, explaining next steps, and what to expect. She gets a 100% rating from us.

— Kathleen C.

What My Clients Say

Penny did an awesome job. We listed our home on Thursday and had offers by Sunday. Very pleased with her attention to detail and professionalism. We highly recommend Penny.

— Joe C.

What My Clients Say

Penny made the entire home-selling process smooth and stress-free. She helped us sell our house quickly while remaining professional, knowledgeable, and responsive every step of the way. No matter how many questions we had or how complicated they were, she always took the time to explain everything clearly and made us feel confident throughout the process. Her expertise, dedication, and commitment to her...

— Sherina S.

What My Clients Say

We had a great experience working with Penny O’Brien to sell our home. We initially listed with another agent, but unfortunately, the home was not marketed or positioned as effectively as we had hoped. After switching to Penny, the difference was immediate. She quickly assessed the situation, gave us practical and thoughtful advice, adjusted the pricing and marketing strategy, and gave the listing a comp...

— Kaili W.

What My Clients Say

We couldn’t have been happier with our experience selling our home! Penny did an outstanding job from start to finish. Thanks to her knowledge, strategy, and exceptional marketing, our house sold very quickly and generated multiple offers. The stager, photographer, and videographer were truly top-notch and showcased our home beautifully. The entire process was handled professionally, efficiently, and wit...

— John & Michelle S.

Featured Properties

Find Your Dream Home Today

Search Now

Work With Penny

Whether helping first-time buyers, move-up buyers, those relocating to the area, downsizing, or finding the right home for their next chapter, Penny provides experienced guidance from the initial search through closing.